What Are the Biggest DIY Website Mistakes Bookkeepers Make?

Building your own bookkeeping website can make a lot of sense, especially when you’re in the early stages of your business.

Maybe you’re working with a limited budget. Maybe you’d rather invest in coaching, software, networking, or another part of your business first. Or maybe you’re comfortable with technology and genuinely enjoy figuring things out yourself.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with DIYing your website.

But there’s an important distinction between doing it yourself and figuring everything out as you go.

If you handed one of your bookkeeping clients a detailed checklist of everything you do each month, they could probably complete some of the tasks themselves. But the checklist wouldn’t automatically give them your experience or your ability to see how all the pieces fit together.

Website projects are similar.

The challenge often isn’t clicking the buttons required to build a website. It’s making the decisions behind those buttons.

Here are some of the most common mistakes that can make a DIY bookkeeping website harder to complete—and less useful once it’s launched.

1. Starting to build before you have a clear website strategy

One of the easiest ways to make a DIY website project frustrating is to start with the technology.

You create an account with a website platform, choose a template, open the homepage editor and then realize:

What am I supposed to put here?

Now you’re trying to figure out your website layout, services, ideal client, marketing message, calls to action, and website copy at the same time.

That’s a lot of decisions to make while staring at an empty screen.

Before worrying about fonts, colors, templates, or page layouts, get clear about the job your website needs to do.

For example:

  • Who are you trying to reach?
  • What bookkeeping services do you want to offer?
  • What problems are those potential clients trying to solve?
  • What do they need to understand about your business?
  • Why might you be a good fit for them?
  • What questions or concerns could keep them from reaching out?
  • What do you want them to do next?

This is one of the reasons Websites for Bookkeepers emphasizes clarity before design. A professional-looking website matters, but design alone can’t compensate for messaging that leaves potential clients confused.

2. Choosing a website template before you know what content you need

Templates can make DIY website projects much easier.

They give you a starting point instead of asking you to design every page from scratch.

But there’s a potential trap: allowing the template to determine what you say.

You find a beautiful homepage with three little boxes, so you decide you need exactly three services.

There’s a large headline area, so you start trying to write something that fits the space rather than something that clearly explains your business.

There’s an About section halfway down the page, so you fill it with a short biography because that’s what the demo showed.

Instead, think of a template as the container for your message.

Your website strategy and content should determine what information needs to be communicated. Then you can adapt the design to support it.

Don’t build your business around the template. Make the template support the business.

3. Writing website copy from your own perspective instead of the client’s

When you’re writing your own website, it’s natural to talk about yourself.

Your experience. Your certifications. Your passion for numbers. Your attention to detail. Your commitment to helping small businesses.

Those details can have a place on your website.

But a prospective client is usually visiting with a different set of questions.

They want to know things like:

Do you work with businesses like mine?

Do you understand what I’m struggling with?

What exactly can you help me with?

What happens if I work with you?

What should I do next?

Your credentials, experience, personality, and expertise can help answer those questions and build trust, but your website doesn’t need to function like an online résumé. It should help a potential client evaluate whether your bookkeeping business might be a good fit.

4. Waiting until you’re building the website to gather everything you need

Website projects can stall because the website itself is difficult.

But they can also stall because you’re missing the pieces that need to go into it.

Before you start building, gather as much of your website content and business information as possible.

That could include your:

  • Logo and brand assets
  • Brand colors and fonts
  • Business contact information
  • Service information
  • Website copy
  • Professional photos or other images
  • Testimonials you have permission to use
  • Social media links
  • Scheduling or contact links
  • Privacy policy and other applicable website policies

You don’t necessarily need an elaborate brand identity or professional photo shoot before you can launch a website. The specific materials you need will depend on your business and the website you’re creating.

The goal is simply to avoid getting halfway through your build and realizing you’re still waiting on—or haven’t created—most of the content.

5. Trying to make the website say everything

Sometimes DIY websites become overwhelming because the business owner tries to answer every possible question on every page.

The homepage becomes enormous. Every service gets several paragraphs. The About page tells the bookkeeper’s entire career history.

More information isn’t always more helpful.

Think about the website as part of a customer journey.

A potential client may discover you through a referral, networking, LinkedIn, Facebook, Google, a lead-generation provider, a community, or another source. They arrive at your website to learn more.

Your website’s job is to help them understand what they’ve found, evaluate whether your business might be relevant to them, and identify an appropriate next step.

You don’t necessarily need to answer every question before they’re allowed to contact you.

You need to answer the right questions.

6. Making the next step difficult to find

Imagine a prospective client has read your homepage, looked at your services, and decided they’d like to talk to you.

Now what?

One of the most important pieces of your website is also one of the simplest: a clear call to action.

Maybe that’s:

Schedule a Consultation

Request a Consultation

Contact Us

Get Started

The exact wording depends on your process.

What’s important is that the visitor understands what to do next and can easily find that action throughout the website.

Your call to action should also match what actually happens after someone clicks.

If you’re asking someone to “Get Started,” for example, make sure the next page explains what getting started involves rather than dropping them into a confusing form with no context.

7. Assuming DIY means you have to do absolutely everything yourself

DIY doesn’t have to be all or nothing.

Maybe you’re comfortable building the website but need help with copy.

Maybe a business coach has already helped you clarify your niche, services, or positioning, and you need to translate that strategy into website messaging.

Maybe you can write your own copy but want a designer to make the finished website look more polished.

Maybe you need an SEO professional to help with your search strategy.

Or perhaps you enjoy none of the technical side and would rather outsource the entire website.

Different professionals solve different parts of the problem, and they can complement one another. A coach can help develop your business strategy. A copywriter can help communicate it. A designer can create the visual experience. An SEO professional can work on search visibility. Your website brings many of those pieces together for the potential client.

You don’t need to assemble a huge marketing team before launching your bookkeeping business.

Get help where it will make the biggest difference for your particular situation.

8. Treating launch day as the finish line

There’s a satisfying moment when your website finally goes live.

But “published” doesn’t mean “finished forever.”

Your business will change.

Your services may change. Your ideal clients may become clearer. You may develop a niche you didn’t have when you started. You might collect better testimonials, get new photos, refine your processes, or change how prospective clients contact you.

The technical side of your website needs attention, too. Depending on the platform and setup, you may need to monitor updates, backups, security, forms, integrations, links, and other functionality.

Your first website doesn’t have to anticipate every version of the business you’ll eventually build.

It needs to support the business you have now while giving you a foundation you can improve as you learn.

Should you DIY your bookkeeping website?

You absolutely can.

For an early-stage bookkeeper with more time than money, DIY may be the most practical option.

The bigger question is whether you have enough clarity to make good decisions while you’re building it.

Before opening your website builder, try to separate website strategy from website construction.

First, figure out who the website is for, what you need to communicate, what content you’ll need, and where you want potential clients to go next.

Then build.

That approach can make DIYing your website much less overwhelming because you aren’t simultaneously trying to figure out your business strategy, marketing message, website copy, design, and technology.

Make your DIY website easier by doing the thinking first

If you’re planning to build or redesign your own bookkeeping website, the Website Readiness Workbook can help you work through the decisions that come before design.

It walks you through areas such as your ideal client, services, marketing message, website content, calls to action, customer journey, and overall website strategy. It also includes the Website Content Assistant, which can help turn the strategy you’ve developed into draft website copy.

You can use that foundation to build your website yourself or take it to the website professional of your choice.

Because DIY doesn’t have to mean starting with a blank screen and figuring everything out along the way.

Meet the Author:

Picture of Chatsoni Brooks

Chatsoni Brooks

Websites for Bookkeepers owner and website strategist sharing tips, tools, and resources to help bookkeepers fix—and avoid—the 3 reasons most websites fail.

Why Consistency Matters in Content Marketing for Bookkeepers

You decide you’re going to get serious about marketing your bookkeeping business. You publish a few social media posts. Maybe you write a blog article. You send an email to your list. Then client work gets busy. A week passes. Then two. Before long, marketing has quietly moved back to the bottom of the list. This is especially easy to

Read More »

What Is the Best Marketing Strategy for Introverted Bookkeepers?

You know you need to market your bookkeeping business. Then someone tells you to attend networking events. Another person says you need to start making Reels. Someone else recommends going live on Facebook, speaking at events, starting a podcast, or booking as many discovery calls as possible. There’s just one problem: You’d rather do almost anything else. Maybe you’re naturally

Read More »

Do you need more information—or more support?

Knowing how to do bookkeeping and knowing how to run a bookkeeping business are two very different skill sets. You can be great at reconciliations, cleanup work, reporting, and helping clients understand their numbers—and still find yourself wondering: How much should I charge? Which clients are actually a good fit for me? How do I stop reinventing my process for

Read More »

Should You Choose a Bookkeeping Niche Before You Have Your First Client?

You keep hearing that you need to niche down. Pick an industry. Define your ideal client. Become the bookkeeper for construction companies, therapists, law firms, real estate investors, or some other specific group. That advice can make sense. A niche can make your marketing clearer and help potential clients recognize more quickly that your services are relevant to them. But

Read More »

Does Niching Down Make Marketing Your Bookkeeping Business Easier?

One of the biggest concerns bookkeeping business owners have about choosing a niche is: “If I get too specific, will I lose potential clients?” That concern makes sense. When you’re building a business, narrowing your marketing can feel like you’re deliberately reducing your opportunities. If you’ve successfully worked with clients across several industries, it may seem even harder to justify

Read More »

Why Bookkeeping Business Owners Don’t Need to Be Good at Everything

There’s a common piece of career advice that goes something like this: If you’re good at sales and marketing, operations and delivery may be harder for you. If you’re great at operations and delivering excellent work, sales and marketing may be the part you struggle with. That’s obviously not a universal rule. Some people are strong in both. But the

Read More »